Key Takeaways
- 01Practices lose collectible revenue to billing execution failures, not only to low reimbursement rates.
- 02In-house billing costs more than the biller's wage. Count benefits, software, clearinghouse fees, training, cover and turnover before comparing it with an outsourced quote.
- 03Six leaks - undercoding, unworked denials, expired authorizations, aging A/R, modifier errors and eligibility failures - are where the money usually goes.
- 04Specialty experience matters. A team that does not know your specialty's rules makes mistakes that repeat on every claim.
- 05You can evaluate a billing company in 15 minutes with seven questions. Specific answers are the pass; slogans are the fail.
If you are reading this, something in your practice's financials is bothering you. Claims sit unpaid longer than they should, denials are climbing, and collections are flat even though your schedule is full.
The money usually goes to billing execution: denied claims that sit until the deadline passes, visits billed below the documented level, authorizations that expired mid-treatment, and claims nobody chased. Denials are the clearest example. In 2024, HealthCare.gov plans denied about 85 million in-network claims, and fewer than 1% of those denials were appealed (KFF analysis of CMS data).
What Your Practice Is Actually Losing (And Why You Don't Know It)
Billing losses are hard to see. Patients come in, claims go out and money is deposited. The gap only shows when you compare what you are owed with what you collect.
- Medical Billing Services
- Medical billing services are companies that manage a practice's billing - from insurance eligibility checks and claim submission to denial management, payer follow-up, payment posting and patient balances.
| Service Component | What It Does for Your Revenue | What Happens Without It |
|---|---|---|
| Insurance eligibility verification | Confirms coverage, cost-sharing and authorization requirements before the visit | Care is delivered to a patient with lapsed coverage and the claim is denied |
| Medical coding | Turns documentation into the codes that decide what you collect | Undercoding loses revenue; overcoding creates audit risk |
| Claim submission and scrubbing | Catches errors before submission | Claims enter a rework cycle of calls, resubmissions and appeals |
| Denial management | Finds the root cause, corrects, and resubmits or appeals | Denied claims become permanent losses once appeal windows close |
| Accounts receivable follow-up | Pursues every unpaid claim before deadlines close | The older a claim gets, the harder it is to collect |
| Prior authorization management | Obtains authorizations and tracks expiration dates | An expired authorization means a denied claim |
| Payment reconciliation | Checks payments against your contracted rates | Underpayments go unnoticed |
| Credentialing and enrollment | Keeps provider enrollment active with each payer | Lapsed credentials stop payment from that payer; credentialing typically takes 60 to 90 days |
Scope varies between billing companies. Some handle only claim submission and payment posting; others handle denials, A/R follow-up, authorizations and credentialing. Know exactly what is included before comparing quotes.
The Real Cost of Keeping Billing In-House
| Cost Category | In-House | Outsourced |
|---|---|---|
| Biller wages and benefits | Your payroll cost | Included in the fee |
| Billing software | Your subscription | Ask whether included |
| Clearinghouse fees | Your fees | Ask whether included or passed through |
| Training | Annual code and payer updates | The billing company's cost |
| Cover during absences | Temp staff or overtime | A team, so no single point of failure |
| Turnover | Recruiting, training and lost productivity | The billing company's cost |
| Unworked denials | Whatever staff have no time for | Ask what share of denials they appeal |
There is also the cost that never shows up in a spreadsheet. When your one biller gets sick or quits, billing stops while payer deadlines keep running. UnitedHealthcare, for example, gives participating providers 90 days to file commercial claims.
The 6 Places Practices Lose Revenue
| Revenue Leak | How It Happens |
|---|---|
| Undercoded visits | Documentation supports a higher level, but the claim goes out lower from habit or caution |
| Denied claims never reworked | Denials sit in a queue nobody has time for, and the appeal window closes |
| Expired prior authorizations | Nobody tracked the expiration date, so later sessions are denied |
| A/R aging past 90 days | The team is busy with new claims, and old ones get harder to collect |
| Modifier and coding errors | A missing modifier on a same-day procedure or the wrong place of service |
| Eligibility failures | Coverage changed or lapsed and nobody checked before the visit |
Denial management, accounts receivable follow-up and prior authorization tracking are how these leaks get closed.
Signs Your Billing Setup Needs Help
- 01Your denial rate keeps rising. Something is wrong in coding, eligibility checks or claim scrubbing.
- 02Your days in A/R keep climbing. You have a follow-up problem.
- 03Billing staff turnover is high. That is a structural problem, not only a hiring one.
- 04Your front desk is also your billing department. Billing needs focus that a busy front desk cannot give it.
- 05You are launching a practice or adding a provider. It is the easiest time to set billing up properly.
In-House vs. Outsourced Billing: An Honest Comparison
In-House Billing vs. Outsourced Billing
In-House Billing Works When
- Single specialty with high, stable volume
- A tenured billing team in your specialty
- Denials stay low and get worked
- A billing manager with no other duties
- A stable payer mix
Outsourced Billing Works When
- Multi-specialty or complex payer mix
- Billing staff turnover or coverage gaps
- Denials rising or going unworked
- Front desk staff doing billing alongside patient duties
- Adding providers, locations or specialties
Outsourcing does not mean giving up control. The right partner gives you monthly reporting on what was collected, denied, appealed and recovered; the wrong one submits claims and goes quiet.
What to Look for in a Medical Billing Service
- Specialty experience: ask how many practices in your specialty they serve and what their denial rate is across them.
- Denial management depth: ask what share of denials they appeal and how they use denial data to fix problems upstream.
- Transparent reporting: charges, collections, denial rate by category, days in A/R and payer-level results every month.
- Your system: confirm they work inside the system you already use, such as SimplePractice, TherapyNotes, CentralReach or athenahealth.
- A dedicated account manager: one person who knows your account and answers the phone.
- HIPAA documentation: ask for their security policies and a signed Business Associate Agreement before any data moves.
How Medical Billing Services Are Priced
| Pricing Model | How It Works | What to Watch For |
|---|---|---|
| Percentage of collections | You pay a percentage of what is collected | Their income rises only when yours does. Confirm what the percentage applies to. |
| Flat fee per claim | A fixed amount per claim submitted | They earn the same whether a claim pays $50 or $500. |
| Flat monthly fee | A fixed payment regardless of volume or results | No link between their income and your collections. |
| Hybrid | A base fee plus a smaller percentage | Make sure the percentage is large enough to matter to them. |
Fintax RCM charges 4-8% of collections. Always compare quotes on total cost, including every add-on you will use.
Why Your Specialty Matters
Every specialty has its own coding rules, modifier requirements and payer policies. A team that handles every specialty the same way makes the same mistakes on every claim.
| Specialty | What a Generalist Gets Wrong |
|---|---|
| Mental health and psychiatry | Bills the medication visit but misses psychotherapy add-ons provided in the same session |
| ABA therapy | Loses track of authorized hours and visit caps |
| Physical, occupational and speech therapy | Misapplies timed-unit rules against total treatment time |
| Orthopedics | Bills follow-up visits inside the global period |
Fintax RCM specializes in billing and credentialing for mental health, behavioral health, psychiatry, psychology, substance use treatment, ABA, speech, occupational and physical therapy practices, in all 50 states.
How to Evaluate Any Billing Company in 15 Minutes
| Question | What a Strong Answer Sounds Like | Red Flag Answer |
|---|---|---|
| What is your average denial rate across clients like me? | A specific number and how it is calculated | "Very low" with no data |
| Who will code my claims? | A defined team with experience in your practice type | "Our coders handle all specialties" |
| What does your monthly reporting include? | Collections, denials by category, A/R aging by payer | "We send a collections summary" |
| Name the top 3 billing mistakes in my specialty. | Immediate, specific answers | A generic answer about "accuracy" |
| What are your contract terms? | No long-term lock-in; your data stays with you | Long minimum terms with exit penalties |
| What happens to my existing aged A/R? | A clear plan for open claims | "We only handle claims from our start date" |
| What does your percentage apply to? | A clear, written answer | Language that could mean either collections or gross charges |
Warning Signs Your Billing Is Underperforming
- Denials rising month over month
- A growing share of A/R past 90 days
- No monthly reporting on denials and A/R aging
- Front desk staff spending hours a day on billing
- Billing staff turnover in the past 18 months
- Collections flat while patient volume is steady
- You do not know your net collection rate
- Your coding has never been audited
What Happens When You Switch Billing Companies
Stage 1 - Discovery and Setup
Review payer contracts, fee schedules, system access, provider credentials and current A/R. Find any credentialing gaps before the transition.
Stage 2 - Parallel Processing
The new team begins processing claims alongside your existing workflow, which catches integration and payer issues early.
Stage 3 - Full Cutover
The new team takes over with no gap in submission, and the previous relationship winds down.
After Cutover - Optimization
Denial patterns get fixed upstream, coding is reviewed and aging comes down.
Before you switch, get a written answer on who will work the claims your previous biller submitted that are still unpaid. Claims nobody works during a transition age past filing and appeal deadlines.
How to Measure Performance After 90 Days
| Metric | What It Tells You |
|---|---|
| Net collection rate | Whether the service is collecting what payers owe you |
| Days in A/R | How actively claims are followed up |
| Denial rate | Whether claims go out accurately the first time |
| Share of claims paid on first submission | The quality of coding, eligibility checks and scrubbing |
| A/R over 90 days | Whether old balances are being worked down |
Agree on these measures in writing before you start, and review them monthly. If you are still comparing vendors, our guide on how to choose a medical billing company lays out the questions in full, or request a free billing review.
Sources & References
- KFF, Claims Denials and Appeals in ACA Marketplace Plans in 2024 - denial and appeal rates on HealthCare.gov plans
- UnitedHealthcare 2026 Administrative Guide - 90-day filing limit for participating providers
- Sources checked October 2026.