Comparison for therapists
Headway vs Alma vs Grow vs Rula vs Your Own Insurance Contracts
Headway, Alma, Grow and Rula put you in network through their own agreements with insurance companies and handle claims for you. In exchange, the platform holds the contract, and your in-network status stays with it if you leave. Your own contracts take 60 to 90 days per insurer to set up and need billing handled, but they belong to you. Which pays more depends on your insurers and your state, so compare real rates.
Update, October 11, 2026: Headway has moved the start of its $9.99 marketplace fee. Its help center, updated October 8, now says the fee rolls out state by state starting November 2026 and reaches every state by the end of 2026. It had first said the fee would start in October in Virginia, Washington, Georgia, Ohio and Illinois.
Reviewed by the Fintax RCM billing team. Last reviewed 2026-10-11.
The side-by-side
Every platform statement below comes from that platform's own pages: Headway, Alma and Grow checked on 2026-10-03, Rula on 2026-10-05, and Headway's marketplace fee on 2026-10-11. Headway's fee is listed because Headway publishes it. For the others, check each platform's current terms.
| Headway | Alma | Grow | Rula | Your own contracts | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who holds the insurance contract | Headway, through "its own payer agreements" | Alma: in network "under Alma's tax ID" | Grow: you are added to Grow's group contracts | Rula: under its group contracts, "even if you're already credentialed with a payer as an individual" | You, under your own NPI and tax ID |
| If you leave | Headway credentialing is separate from any contracts you hold yourself | In-network status is under Alma's tax ID | "Your enrollment status won't transfer outside of Grow" | Rula's Support Team moves your clients to another Rula provider | Your contracts stay with you |
| Who handles claims | The platform | The platform | The platform | The platform | You, or a billing service you choose |
| Per-session platform fee | $9.99 per session with new clients who find you through its marketplace, state by state from November 2026 (all states by the end of 2026) | Check current terms | Check current terms | Check current terms | None. Billing costs apply if you outsource it |
| Who sets your rate | Set through the platform's agreements | Set through the platform's agreements | Set through the platform's agreements | Set by Rula's contracts with insurers | Agreed between you and each insurer |
| Time before you can bill | Check the platform's current estimate | Check the platform's current estimate | Check the platform's current estimate | Check the platform's current estimate | Usually 60 to 90 days per insurer |
How much do Headway, Alma, Grow and Rula pay therapists?
None of them publishes a pay rate on its public site, as of 2026-10-05. Each one says pay depends on your license, your state and the insurer. Here is what each says, and where you see your own rate.
| Platform | What it says about pay | Where you see your rate |
|---|---|---|
| Headway | "Earnings vary by license type and location." | In the Headway provider portal, by insurer and session type, once you join. Its practice consultants answer before that. |
| Alma | "Our rates are highly confidential." Members are asked not to share them. | Inside Alma, once you are a member. |
| Grow | "Pay rates vary by payor, state, session type, and license type." | In the Grow provider portal, filtered to your license and states. Other states on request. |
| Rula | "This varies by license type and location." Rates "are set based on the current contracts we have with our payor partners." | On a call with Rula's team, after its sign-up form. |
Therapists have started comparing notes for Headway. SingleAim's May 2024 analysis of about 300 therapist reports put Headway's average around $107 for a 60-minute session, close to the $106 average for contracting directly.
It swings by payer. SingleAim and the 671 reports on TherapistRates.org both show Headway paying more than direct contracts with Aetna and less with Blue Cross; they disagree on Cigna and Optum. These are self-reported numbers, so treat them as directional, not exact.
Rula: what to know before you join
SonderMind works on a similar model: it lists you under its tax ID and group NPI, and says this does not affect your individual contracts.
- Rula credentials you under its group contracts, even if you already hold your own contract with that insurer.
- Rula says therapists "are hired as 1099 contractors."
- Rula verifies benefits, sends claims and collects copays, coinsurance and deductibles.
- Rula bills only the insurers it has contracts with. You can see other clients through your own practice.
- If you leave, Rula's Support Team moves your clients to another Rula provider.
- Rula says therapists "may not transfer Rula-referred clients" to their own practice. A client may follow you if the move is the client's own idea and you did not ask.
- Rula accepts LMFTs, LCSWs, LPCCs and licensed psychologists.
When a platform is the better choice
- You are just starting out and want insured clients quickly
- You want no billing or credentialing work at all
- The platform's rates for your insurers are as good as, or better than, direct contracts in your state
When your own contracts make more sense
Rates can change on either path. Behavioral Health Business reported that Aetna lowered rates for therapists contracted through Alma, effective July 15, 2026. Insurers can also change fee schedules on direct contracts, so read each contract's terms.
- Your caseload is full and platform rates have dropped
- You want to grow into a group practice with your own clinicians
- You want your insurance relationships to belong to your practice
- Direct rates in your state beat the platform after billing costs
Questions to ask before you choose
- Whose contract am I billing under, mine or the platform's?
- If I leave, what happens to my in-network status and my clients?
- Who decides my rate, and how will I hear about rate changes?
- Can I see clients from the same insurer both on the platform and on my own?
- Who handles denials, appeals and unpaid claims, and how will I see their status?
- What notice do I have to give, and are there any client terms in the agreement?
If Medicare is part of your plan
Since January 1, 2024, licensed marriage and family therapists and mental health counselors can enroll in Medicare and bill on their own. Enrollment is done online in PECOS. Medicare pays them 75% of what it pays a clinical psychologist.
Licensed clinical psychologists can enroll too, and Medicare pays them the full fee schedule rate when they accept assignment. If Medicare clients matter to your practice, ask each platform whether it supports them before you decide.
How to decide with real numbers
Your own contracts often pay more, but not always. A platform's negotiated rate can be higher than what an insurer first offers a new solo practice, so compare real numbers before you decide.
Write down what the platform pays you
For your three or four most common insurers, note what you are paid per session type today.
Find what each insurer pays you directly
Ask each insurer for its fee schedule for your license type in your state before you sign a contract, so you are comparing real numbers.
Subtract what doing it yourself costs
Billing (for example, 4-8% of collections if you outsource it), credentialing ($150 per application, per provider with Fintax RCM), and practice software.
Compare the totals
If your own contracts still pay more after those costs, they make financial sense. If not, staying on the platform may be the better choice for now.
| Worked example (example numbers, not real rates) | Per session |
|---|---|
| Platform pays you | $100 |
| Your own contract pays | $120 |
| Billing fee at 6% of $120 | -$7.20 |
| You keep on your own contract | $112.80 |
If the numbers favor your own contracts, our guide to leaving Headway, Alma or Grow has the steps in order, from credentialing to your last session on the platform.
Common questions
- Does Headway charge therapists a fee?
- Yes, from November 2026. Headway deducts $9.99 per session for new clients who find you through its marketplace, for as long as you see them. It rolls out state by state and reaches every state by the end of 2026. Clients you bring yourself or who book through your direct link are not charged.
- Why is Headway controversial?
- Two changes in October 2026 drew pushback from therapists: Headway's $9.99 marketplace fee, which repeats on every session (a petition asked for a one-time fee instead), and, two weeks later, a new agreement that included a permanent license to providers' name, image and voice. Headway paused the agreement after the backlash. Behavioral Health Business reported that signed copies would be nullified.
- How much does Headway pay therapists?
- Headway does not publish a per-session rate. It says earnings vary by license type and location, and you see your rates by insurer and session type in its provider portal after you join. Compare that number with what each insurer would pay you directly.
- Does Alma or Headway pay more?
- Neither publishes its rates, so there is no public answer. The self-reported rate data on this page covers Headway only. To compare, ask each platform for its rate for your main insurers in your state, and put the numbers side by side with direct contracts.
- How much does Rula pay therapists?
- Rula does not publish a per-session rate; it says pay varies by license type and location, and is set from its contracts with insurers. It pays every other week on Fridays, and says you are paid even if a client no-shows or a claim is denied. Notes are due within 48 hours, and Rula may reduce pay if they are late.
- Can I take my clients with me if I leave Rula?
- Rula says therapists may not transfer Rula-referred clients to their own practice. A client may follow you if the move is the client's own idea and you did not ask. Read your Rula agreement before you plan a move.
- Is Headway, Alma or Grow better for therapists?
- It depends on your insurers, your state and how much admin you want to handle. All three put you in network through their own agreements, so compare the rates each offers for your main insurers, and compare them with direct contracts.
- What is the difference between Alma and Headway for therapists?
- The main differences are cost and timing. Alma charges a membership of $95 a month billed annually, or $125 billed monthly, while Headway is free to join but keeps an unpublished share of each insurance payment and, from November 2026, $9.99 a session on clients from its marketplace. Alma says credentialing takes up to 45 days; Headway says 3 weeks to 4 months.
- Do I own my insurance contracts on Headway, Alma, Grow or Rula?
- No. Headway credentials through its own payer agreements, Alma credentials members under Alma's tax ID, and Grow and Rula add you to their group contracts. Your own contracts are the only ones you take with you.
- Can I be on a platform and have my own contracts?
- Headway says credentialing you hold independently is separate from its own process. Check each platform's terms on seeing clients from the same insurer both ways.
- How much does it cost to get my own contracts?
- An NPI is free, and the CAQH Provider Data Portal is free for clinicians. Fintax RCM charges $150 per application, per provider, and billing is 4-8% of collections if you want us to handle it.
Sources
- Headway Help Center, "Understanding the marketplace service fee", checked 2026-10-11
- Headway Help Center, "Credentialing with Headway", checked 2026-10-03
- Alma Help Center, "Get Credentialed with Alma's Insurance Program", checked 2026-10-26
- Alma Help Center, "Request Changes to Your Alma Membership" (prices, cancellation, the 20th-of-the-month deadline), checked 2026-10-15
- Grow Therapy Provider Help Center, "Enrollment and Credentialing FAQ" (updated August 30, 2026), checked 2026-10-03
- Headway, For providers ("Earnings vary by license type and location"; joining is free with no ongoing costs) and Help Center, viewing your rates, checked 2026-10-26
- Headway Help Center, "Rates and agreements" (Headway keeps a small percentage of session payments), checked 2026-10-22
- Change.org, "Urge Headway to adopt a fair fee structure for marketplace referrals" (created October 1, 2026), checked 2026-10-17
- Behavioral Health Business, "Headway Faces Backlash After Unveiling New Opt-In Patient Marketplace With $10 Per-Session Fee" (October 2, 2026), checked 2026-10-17
- Behavioral Health Business, "Headway Issues, Then Retracts New Clinician Contracts After Backlash" (October 19, 2026), checked 2026-10-23
- SingleAim, "How Much Does Headway Pay Therapists?" (about 300 crowdsourced therapist rate reports, May 2024), checked 2026-10-18
- TherapistRates.org, "Does Headway pay more than your own insurance contract?" (671 self-reported 90837 rates), checked 2026-10-18
- Alma Help Center, "Membership Overview" (rates are confidential), checked 2026-10-05
- Grow Therapy Help Center, "View your payor rates", checked 2026-10-05
- Rula, For providers (provider page), checked 2026-10-05
- Rula Therapist Support, "Credentialing and payer enrollment FAQs", checked 2026-10-05
- Rula Therapist Support, "Your pay rates", checked 2026-10-05
- Rula Therapist Support, "Rula therapist payments guide", checked 2026-10-05
- Rula Therapist Support, 1099 status, checked 2026-10-05
- Rula Therapist Support, "Practice Guideline: Client Transfers and Solicitation Outside of Rula", checked 2026-10-05
- SonderMind, "Credentialing FAQ" (updated December 19, 2023), checked 2026-10-05
- Behavioral Health Business, "Aetna Cuts Rates with Alma-Contracted Therapists" (May 21, 2026), checked 2026-10-03
- CMS, Marriage and family therapists and mental health counselors (last modified July 20, 2026), checked 2026-10-03
- CMS, Medicare & Mental Health Coverage (MLN1986542, March 2026), checked 2026-10-03
- DataSpring (formerly CAQH), For Clinicians, checked 2026-10-03
- CMS, NPI fact sheet (December 2024), checked 2026-10-03
Related
Start your own credentialing before you leave
We file and follow up on every insurer application at $150 per application, per provider, and keep you updated on each one's status.